Page 3 of 3 < 1 2 3
Topic Options
Rate This Topic
#105600 - Mon Feb 19 2007 11:31 PM Re: 2007/2/14 avie at Hakkoda
sock_monkey Offline
SJ'er with 400+ posts

Registered: Tue Feb 01 2005
Posts: 461
Loc: Vancouver, Canada
almost anything will slide under the right conditions, safe travel techniques minimize the impact if you do happen to be there when it does.

i'm very sad to hear about this. i've skied with Simon and with the Sukayu Onsen guides before. i was invited to go there two weeks ago for a tour with the head guide.

i have a lot of thoughts going through my head about this and can't sort them all out right now. i need to read the reports.

Top
#105601 - Tue Feb 20 2007 05:44 AM Re: 2007/2/14 avie at Hakkoda
SerreChe Offline
SJ'er with 1000+ posts

Registered: Sun Dec 03 2000
Posts: 1688
Loc: Prev 6° 37' 2'' E 44° 53' 12''...
powdernator, you guys did an incredible job out there. You all deserve recognition for what you did!

Top
#105602 - Sun Feb 25 2007 07:39 PM Re: 2007/2/14 avie at Hakkoda
The Takayama Tearer Offline
SJ'er with 75+ posts

Registered: Sun Jul 09 2006
Posts: 78
Loc: Vicco!
Big Respect to Powdernator!

Top
#105603 - Wed Feb 28 2007 06:15 PM Re: 2007/2/14 avie at Hakkoda
Mantas Offline
SJ'er with 2000+ posts

Registered: Sun Jun 18 2006
Posts: 2087
Loc: Australia
What were the Aussies doing up there?....It's a fair question. For the devistated party that got hit by this Avie it's a good job they were. Five of the seven Aussies were fully trained ski patrollers from Thredbo, fully equipped with shovels, beacons, poles and first aid kits.
Judging by this story in the Sydney Morning Herald, they played a major part in the rescue. It took four hours for the rescue party to arrive and get them off the hill.

They said the storm set in quicker than expected. I'm not going to pass gudgement on any involved as I don't know enough about Avies. One thing though it did answer my previous question on this topic. How safe are backcountry tours?

If you look at it from a purely statistical point of view, is it any more dangerous than any other risky guided activity?
How many people around the world would get killed each year cycling, kayaking, caving, scuba diving ect.
_________________________
The older I get. The better I was.

Top
#105604 - Wed Feb 28 2007 06:26 PM Re: 2007/2/14 avie at Hakkoda
Mantas Offline
SJ'er with 2000+ posts

Registered: Sun Jun 18 2006
Posts: 2087
Loc: Australia
Sorry...I just posted above without reading the second page \:o

Yeah good work Powdernater.
How fortunate were those guys to have you and the Aussies turn up?
There's 7 Aussie we can be proud of back here.
_________________________
The older I get. The better I was.

Top
#105605 - Wed Feb 28 2007 10:17 PM Re: 2007/2/14 avie at Hakkoda
SerreChe Offline
SJ'er with 1000+ posts

Registered: Sun Dec 03 2000
Posts: 1688
Loc: Prev 6° 37' 2'' E 44° 53' 12''...
I think Montoya mentionned aerlier that this avalanche went off on a slope less than 30deg. Statistically I have read that only 3% of avalanches happen on slopes less than 30deg. Unfortunate. Yes Manta these guys all did a great job, and let's not forget about Simon.

Top
#105606 - Thu Mar 01 2007 09:07 PM Re: 2007/2/14 avie at Hakkoda
asuasuman Offline
SJ'er

Registered: Thu Mar 01 2007
Posts: 4
Loc: aussie
here is myAussie mate's version of the rescue. Pure luck that some pros were on the mountain. Good on yah Ossie! Oy Oy Oy!!!



in case the link goes cold


Helping to save the lives of 22 people was all in a day's work for seven Australian skiers, writes Robert Wainwright.

THEY set off early on Valentine's Day to explore one of northern Japan's remote mountain tops, seven Australians bound together by a passion for finding and skiing virgin powder snow.

But by the time they came down from the mountain that night these veteran snow men, five of them members of Thredbo's elite Ski Patrol, had helped to save the lives of 22 Japanese skiers caught in an avalanche that buried one survivor for 90 minutes, killed two men and landed eight in hospital, where they remain with broken bones and ruptured lungs, bowels and kidneys.

Amazingly, when their job was done the group simply walked away and had a hot bath. Now, just a week after the drama - and back in Australia to tell their tale for the first time - they insist there be little fuss. However, in Japan, one of the world's biggest ski markets, they have left a lasting mark on rescue co-ordination and training methods.

Yesterday, they reflected publicly about the five hours they spent in the eye of a white-out. The Thredbo patrol members Jonathan Disher, Ross McSwiney, Mark Spilsbury, Glen Kirkwood and Roger Campbell and their friends David Stewart-Thompson and David Brown said they had arrived in high spirits at the Hakkoda resort in the early hours of February 14.

It was the last leg of an unforgettable two-week holiday exploring the remote powder country of northern Japan - a final blast before heading home.

Aware that the weather was deteriorating but told there was still several hours to ski safely, they caught a mid-morning cable car packed with skiers up the mountain. Because of their plans to powder ski away from known areas, they carried rescue beacons, first-aid kits, GPS navigation gear, shovels, two-way radios and other emergency equipment.

The car disgorged 80 or so skiers, most of whom headed back down the slope. They included a group of 24 on a tour organised by a local inn. But the Australians were going further, accompanied by an American guide, and climbed an 80-metre face towards a nearby ridge. By the time they reached the top 15 minutes later the weather had changed dramatically.

It was 11am and the storm front hit with wind speeds of 120kmh. The snow was horizontal and, unbeknown to them, authorities had cleared the mountain and were about to issue an avalanche warning.

"I don't think anyone would admit it, but we were shitting ourselves," Mr Disher recounted yesterday. "The sky was white, the ground was white and the air was white. There was simply nothing to see.

"Getting caught in high winds at Thredbo, where we know the terrain intimately, is one thing, but this was unfamiliar territory.

"The wind chill factor had probably dropped to minus 20. We knew the key to survival was getting down off the mountain as quickly as possible."

The men made their way slowly down the ridge to the tree line, where visibility would be better. At the trees was a marked route leading to an access road and safety. "The guide was leading and I was behind him," Mr Disher said. "I could see ahead of us there were several people kneeling over someone in the snow. As we got through the trees we could see the devastation everywhere."

The front half of the 24-strong tour group had been hit by an avalanche, which had smashed into them through a forest. At least one man was dead and several lay badly injured. Those not obviously injured were staggering around the slope, stunned and disoriented. They were all in trouble.

Mr Disher and his colleagues quickly assessed the situation. "No one seemed to know what to do so I guess our training took over and we just took control of the situation. One of the boys shouted, 'There's a hand sticking out of the snow,' so four of us got out our shovels and started digging. Then we saw another one.

"We had to get them out quickly. Snow compresses around you like setting concrete; you can't move and you can't breathe. It's the most frightening thing you can imagine."

The second buried skier was a woman, one of six in the group. She was seriously hurt with a ruptured kidney, burst bowel and a punctured lung, but survived.

Another man did not survive despite desperate CPR attempts: "You always hope. Ross was pumping his chest and David [Stewart-Thompson] was doing the pulse, but he was already gone."

The drama was not over. The Japanese ski party was still in shock, as was the Australian's guide, their only means of communication. After demanding a head count it became apparent that another man was missing, buried somewhere beneath them on the slope. He was probably already dead.

They began to search in a grid pattern using probes - aluminium tubes which can be linked together like tent poles to make three metre-long sticks, then used to prod beneath the surface of the snow. Usually they are used as a last resort to find bodies.

After an hour of an exhausting search the missing man was found buried face down near one of the other buried skiers.

"We were resigned to finding a body, but as we dug him out a foot twitched," Mr Disher recalled. "When we got his head out he groaned. The elation was just unbelievable. He was alive, even though he'd been under the snow for at least 90 minutes.

"His helmet was badly dented and his nose smashed as well as a wrist. He'd hit a tree, survived, and then buried somehow in an air bubble."

The emergency was far from over. There were still more than 30 people trapped on a mountain slope in appalling weather, among them two dead and eight injured, and help was still at least three hours away.

The Japanese authorities, now alerted to their plight by two-way radio, were struggling to put together a rescue team, eventually mobilising a combination of fire brigade, police and army personnel.

The first person to reach them was a young woman, another ski guide, who hiked up the slopes carrying hot tea. Litters to carry the dead and injured would take four hours to arrive.

In the meantime, the Australian contingent built shelters. "We were wet and tired ourselves, and couldn't communicate because no one apart from our guide spoke any English and he was struggling," Mr Disher said.

"We had to keep ourselves occupied so we built igloos around each of the injured, even a couple of snow caves into the slopes so people could get out of the conditions."

It was 4.30pm before the main party was ready to bring the injured down the slope, helped by the Australians. They carried a litter before disappearing back to their lodge.

It would be several hours before anyone realised the role they had played. By the next morning they were fielding television interviews.

The Japanese Government is now planning a ceremony in Sydney to formally thank the men.

Jonathan Disher still reckons the fuss is unnecessary. "I suppose we view it as all in a day's work. It's why we train and why the patrol is important."


Story Picture: ``As we dug him out a foot twitched'' ... Australian skiers come to the aid of a man who spent 90 minutes buried in snow.

Top
#105607 - Thu Mar 01 2007 10:27 PM Re: 2007/2/14 avie at Hakkoda
SerreChe Offline
SJ'er with 1000+ posts

Registered: Sun Dec 03 2000
Posts: 1688
Loc: Prev 6° 37' 2'' E 44° 53' 12''...
Not to put down what those guys did, but what I did notice in this article is that it was really biased in trying to make it sounds like the ozzies were the only ones who knew what was going on and that Simon was just there along for the ride. Too much oy oy oy / chest beating for my liking. Not those guys' fault, just some dumb journalist.

"members of Thredbo's ELITE Ski Patrol" A place well known for its huge mountains gnarly runs and massive dumps.

"they carried rescue beacons, first-aid kits, GPS navigation gear, shovels, two-way radios " then later followed by "The Japanese authorities, now alerted to their plight by two-way radio" implying they alerted the authorities themselves. Simon obviously called the authorities as those guys could not speak japanese, nor would they know which frequency to call in (fyi Simon is a short-wave radio fanatic).

"The Japanese ski party was still in shock, as was the Australian's guide". I guess he was just bumbling around doing nothing eh?

"no one apart from our guide spoke any English and he was struggling". Nice one. Let's step all over his head to make ourselves look good. Very Galant.

"After DEMANDING a head count" good choice of words there.

"in Japan, one of the world's biggest ski markets, they have left a lasting mark on rescue co-ordination and training methods" Modesty is one of their many qualities as one of them would say.

"They began to search in a grid pattern using probes - aluminium tubes which can be linked together like tent poles to make three metre-long sticks,". I understand that not everybody knows what they are, so no complaints here, I just like the way it is explained. By the way all probes are 3m long ;\) , they only come in one size.

What these guys did was amazing, but this article is really painful to read. The scary thing is that it is the SMH, not some unknown newspaper. Thankfully not all press articles down under are so populist.

Top
#105608 - Thu Mar 01 2007 11:10 PM Re: 2007/2/14 avie at Hakkoda
Mudguts Offline
SJ'er with 200+ posts

Registered: Mon Apr 22 2002
Posts: 274
Loc: Tokyo, Tokyo, Japan
I can't see any reason to nickpick over details in a recount of the event. They were in the right place at the right time in terrible conditions and SAVED LIVES!

Top
#105609 - Fri Mar 02 2007 12:09 AM Re: 2007/2/14 avie at Hakkoda
asuasuman Offline
SJ'er

Registered: Thu Mar 01 2007
Posts: 4
Loc: aussie
what ever

there are always two views of any situation but how qualified was the guide to be in avie country?

Anyone one can call themselves a guide and this cowboy's web page has nothing about his training and qualifications other than being bi-lingual and having boarded the mountain for over ten years. Not really the primary consideration in a crisis where people are dying.

Top
#105610 - Fri Mar 02 2007 02:02 AM Re: 2007/2/14 avie at Hakkoda
soubriquet Offline
SJ'er with 5000+ posts

Registered: Mon Jun 27 2005
Posts: 5347
Loc: Oishida
Hey big swinging dick.

My passport says born in Bridgetown. Your post reminds me of why I left Orstraya.

Pathetic
_________________________
If you can`t fix it with a hammer, it`s an electrical fault.

Top
#105611 - Fri Mar 02 2007 06:09 AM Re: 2007/2/14 avie at Hakkoda
soubriquet Offline
SJ'er with 5000+ posts

Registered: Mon Jun 27 2005
Posts: 5347
Loc: Oishida
Dickhead

Looks like slightly tinted people 3, Orstraya 0

"THE Indian army and police rescued three foreign skiers stranded on a peak in Indian Kashmir after heavy snow triggered avalanches, the army said today.

The trio got stuck near Sunshine peak overlooking Gulmarg, the region's top ski destination, 52 kilometres north of summer capital Srinagar.

"The three remained stuck in the snow for two days," the army said.

"The (rescue) teams, after crossing very inhospitable terrain, found the three foreign nationals and brought them to Gulmarg late Wednesday evening (local time)".

The army said the three were "wet and cold and unable to move".

There were no further details on their condition.

The army identified the three skiers as Israelis Gay Landen, 32, and Ido Neigu, 31, and Norwegian Franciska Rogne, 25.

Last month, Australian climber and skier Shaun Kratzer, 31, died in an avalanche while skiing at a height of 4000m near Apherwat mountain at Gulmarg.

Gulmarg resort boasts thousands of unmarked vertical descents and has virtually no restrictions on off-piste skiing.

This year, several hundred Westerners have been skiing in the heavily-snowed area which falls close to the militarised de facto border dividing Kashmir between India and Pakistan."
_________________________
If you can`t fix it with a hammer, it`s an electrical fault.

Top
#105612 - Fri Mar 02 2007 12:28 PM Re: 2007/2/14 avie at Hakkoda
SerreChe Offline
SJ'er with 1000+ posts

Registered: Sun Dec 03 2000
Posts: 1688
Loc: Prev 6° 37' 2'' E 44° 53' 12''...
The front pic on Simon's website is a bit funny but calling him a cowboy is easy mud-slinging. Being bilingual when you need to call for rescue in Japan is useful so is the 10 years' experience on the mountain. I have been touring with Simon before and he did a great job. As for certifications, I do not know of many people with true guide certifications in Japan. That's just the way it is here. To be honest I would rather go with a guy who knows the mountain and has 10 years experience on it than with a fully certified guide who has not much experience of the place. By the way, the only time I ever got caught in an avalanche was with a professional guide in Europe (they're supposed to have the toughest standards as well).

Anyways, the rant was about the tone of the article. Nobody denies the fact that the rescuers did a great job and saved lives. I hope you guys can get over it.

Interesting post Soub. I always wondered about mountains in that neck of the woods. They must have some pretty huge vert over there. Maybe next road-trip!

Top
#105613 - Fri Mar 02 2007 03:45 PM Re: 2007/2/14 avie at Hakkoda
Mantas Offline
SJ'er with 2000+ posts

Registered: Sun Jun 18 2006
Posts: 2087
Loc: Australia
The article does have a wiff of sensationalism and nationalism I admit, so lets not confuse one journo's need to sell papers with the brave deeds of these guys. Aussie or not. Only the guys on the mountain know what really happened. My mate was with this group of Thredbo patrollers the week before this, so I guess I'll get it 3rd hand when I see him.

Soub- Not sure why your attacking us all.
_________________________
The older I get. The better I was.

Top
#105614 - Fri Mar 02 2007 05:10 PM Re: 2007/2/14 avie at Hakkoda
asuasuman Offline
SJ'er

Registered: Thu Mar 01 2007
Posts: 4
Loc: aussie
Not doubting he's a great guy, But the point is , Is he trained to deal with emergencies? If not, guiding in an avalanche prone area isn't very professional so that would qualify him as a cowboy, in the loose and reckless sense. If he is trained it would be a good business practice to state the fact in his sales pitch which he hasn't done.

Top
Page 3 of 3 < 1 2 3


Moderator:  SJ#2, SJ#3, SJ#4, SJ#5, SJBot, SJForums 
SnowJapan Chat Box
The SnowJapan Chat Box is currently closed.
Who's Online
9 Registered (golf74, ianbc, NewYen, nuejam, one8s, Paris88, Sciclone, stemik, 1 invisible), 206 visible guests and 11 others.
Key: Admin, Global Mod, Mod
Forum Stats
7252 Members
11 Forums
16246 Topics
296866 Posts
143 Average daily posts (last week)
223 Posts in the last 24 hrs

Max Online: 2075 @ Fri Apr 04 2008 09:23 AM
Regular Updates




SnowJapan Information
SnowJapan.com
Interview about SnowJapan
About SnowJapan
Site Map
News & Announcements
Contact Us
Forums Registration
Newest Members
jaxjazzy, k0chan, t0neh, StickyVix, Tao and Zen, therock23, virgile
7252 Registered Members


SNOWJAPAN.COM   :   SNOWJAPAN.TV
the japan winter sports guide & community

JAPAN SKI & SNOWBOARD RESORTS
Japan Snow Resorts Index : Resorts by Prefecture : Resort Spotlights : Ski Town Maps : Resort Reviews : Resort Photos : Search Resorts
JAPAN SKI ACCOMMODATION & PLACES TO STAY
Places to Stay Index (All Regions) : Hokkaido : Nagano : Niigata : Gunma : Iwate : Yamagata : Fukushima
JAPAN SNOW & WEATHER DAILY REPORTING
Daily Reporting Index : Niseko Now : Furano Now : Hakuba Now : Nozawa Now : Shiga Kogen Now : Yuzawa Now : Naeba Now : Minakami Now : Myoko Now : Now Calendar : Resort Webcams
JAPAN SKI TOWN GUIDES
Town Guides Index : Niseko Town Guide : Furano Town Guide : Hakuba Town Guide : Nozawa Town Guide : Shiga Kogen Town Guide : Yuzawa & Naeba Town Guide : Minakami Town Guide
GUIDES & INFORMATION
Travel Info : General Info : Services : Lessons in English : Tours & Services : Jobs Available : Features & Interviews : Photo Galleries : Reader Photo Galleries

About SnowJapan : Contact Us : Site Map : Search : Start Here!
SnowJapan © 2008
www.snowjapanforums.com