Page 2 of 2 < 1 2
Topic Options
Rate This Topic
#252651 - Wed Jan 09 2008 09:20 PM Re: aussies recognized [Re: quattro]
samurai Offline
SJ'er with 1000+ posts

Registered: Mon Nov 13 2006
Posts: 1022
Loc: Yamagata
quattro, you have got to work on that grammar, mate. That was painful.

As far as avi-gear is concerned for the inbounds stuff, I wouldn't sweat any groomers/courses virtually anywhere. (I'm a a certified Level 3 Avi cert from American Avalanche Institute.)

Off piste, however, in or out of bounds is completely different. I've ridden slides in-bounds. My work on Patrol taught me more about starting slides than anything. I can't even count (or estimate) how many slides I've started.

All of the recent inbounds slides making the news recently are offpiste, on big terrain. Even after the bombs and ski-cutting, there are always lingering slabs that could take out anyone and push them into a tree.

If you are willing to carry a shovel and a beacon, even if you are taking care of kids on greens, then I applaud you. If only that were standard... however, my training took years and heeps of cash. I don't expect the avaerage recreational skier to be willing to front that to go play in the snow.

either way, all snow slides. it's physics. (let me rephrase that- all snow IS SLIDING... right now.) Think silly putty. stretch it slowly, or break it by pulling it apart too quickly.
_________________________
Don't wait up mom, I'm off to kill summer.

Top
#252657 - Wed Jan 09 2008 09:39 PM Re: aussies recognized [Re: samurai]
tsondaboy Offline
SJ'er with 3000+ posts

Registered: Tue Oct 26 2004
Posts: 3542
Loc: 東京 (Tokyo)
To tell you the truth, regardless of avie danger, I always carry my back pack with me. The balance on a snowboard is so much different without it, so like quatro, I have it on all the time with my shovel and some more staff in.
_________________________
████
█02█
████

Top
#252669 - Wed Jan 09 2008 10:10 PM Re: aussies recognized [Re: tsondaboy]
Mamabear Offline
SJ'er with 1000+ posts

Registered: Sun Nov 04 2007
Posts: 1586
Loc: Perth Western Australia
OK..just to be clear - at this point there is no out of bounds for me. I SAW snow for the first time in April - yes that is right APRIL 2007! I know ... total n00b!

However I am currently on my 4th snow trip in that time - and have had privates each time. I am geared up, and while old and unfit - ready to have a crack.

I have NEVER ridden with a back pack before - just me and my board. I added the helmet last trip - and as the only uninjured adult to make sure the kids don't let loose a flying snowboard, or end up in a tree well - I am thinking I might need to carry some Mummy equipment. (The stuff Daddy used to carry).

I have a slightly ADD/obsessive personality (be nice now) - so I have done masses of research on safety on snow, got a hold of research papers on injury rate in snowboarders v skiers (including other variables such as age/helmet use) etc etc. I have read the info, and watched the vid's on Avalanche safety. I haven't done a course yet - WOULD LOVE to though. Ohhh..and I am First Aid and rescue trained (for non-snow conditions).

I dont think I know everything - far from it. But I get really ticked when people take up new sports/interest/etc and launch in without even considering risk minimisation, whether that be for themselves or for those around them.

I wont be carrying Avie gear on piste. I have not bought any. But I have at least thought through what I would do, and how I could improvise if I were in the position to assist someone - be they my kid or someone else - be they immersed in a pile of POW, hit by an Avie or injured in a fall..

Way I see it - when you buy a lift pass as an adult you take on some level of responsibility for those around you.

Top
#252676 - Wed Jan 09 2008 10:26 PM Re: aussies recognized [Re: Mamabear]
samurai Offline
SJ'er with 1000+ posts

Registered: Mon Nov 13 2006
Posts: 1022
Loc: Yamagata
FWIW mamabear, I think you're in the clear aside from "Huge" dumps.

being a nOOb with kids, I imagine you are far from getting hit. It's great that you're paying attention though. And- that is where the "Huge" dump factor comes in. Huge dumps have buried resort base areas. But even those resorts are at the bottom of huge faces.

Enjoy the winter, mamabear. Your kids are lucky to have you taking the precautions while introducing them to the glory of snow. These trees in japan are keeping you much safer than may be assumed.
_________________________
Don't wait up mom, I'm off to kill summer.

Top
#252687 - Wed Jan 09 2008 11:10 PM Re: aussies recognized [Re: samurai]
Big Dogg Offline
SJ'er with 25+ posts

Registered: Sat Dec 02 2006
Posts: 41
Loc: Nagano City
Just a quick comment about the inbound slides. They DO happen but it would be more likely at a resort that has some steeps (not too many in Japan). Is 38 degrees the correct angle?

Also quatro mentioned a slide at Squaw Valley in Tahoe. Well, I used to ride at a nearby resort (Sierra at Tahoe). I checked the reports. They reported 93 inches in the last 7 days - that's over 200cm! Squaw's report was similar. Those are pretty unusual circumstances.
_________________________
POW POW POW

Top
#252781 - Thu Jan 10 2008 11:45 AM Re: aussies recognized [Re: Big Dogg]
Fattwins Offline
SJ'er with 10000+ posts

Registered: Sun Sep 22 2002
Posts: 13091
Loc: Japan
The inbounds slides are happening on a scary layer in the northwest snow pack.

Mamabear does not need to run out and gear up to protect her kids. A shovel alone wont do crap in a slide. youll need to spend 3000 bucks gearing the family up for something that wont happen. Stay on piste. Enter through gates if you are riding inbounds trees. If you follow those guidelines then dont worry. If you are hiking to a peak or cutting into no go terrain then you should be ready to save yourself.

The present NA snowpack is going to see many closed runs for a while. The Avies that happened, happened an hour or more after the areas were opened and had skier traffic. That type of instability is quite rare.

Top
#252785 - Thu Jan 10 2008 11:56 AM Re: aussies recognized [Re: Fattwins]
Go Native Offline
SJ'er with 750+ posts

Registered: Fri Dec 30 2005
Posts: 792
Loc: Kutchan
As far as I know there has never been an inbounds avie that has killed anyone in Niseko. And the only avvies that have caused deaths are in areas that are strictly off limits.
Mama unless you are climbing the peak and hitting some of the back bowls or Jacksons there is little chance of you coming into contact with an avvie. The bus ride from the airport was probably far more dangerous \:\)

Top
#252970 - Thu Jan 10 2008 10:19 PM Re: aussies recognized [Re: Go Native]
Mamabear Offline
SJ'er with 1000+ posts

Registered: Sun Nov 04 2007
Posts: 1586
Loc: Perth Western Australia
Yeah yeah - I know that... my point is that as a newbie to the sport I am keen to make sure I know as much about safety as I need (and more)- that is the super responsible person in me.

Then there is the other me - the one that sent the kids home with Dad for a hot chocolate today and while everyone else ditched me for the comforts of a heater, convinced my 14 yr old to ride with me one more time. At the top of the lift we ditched each other and just went to POW heaven for a short while. One run - no kids - and pushing myself to my personal limits. Ohhh yeah..in bounds - but THAT is what *I* am talking about!

Top
#252994 - Thu Jan 10 2008 11:44 PM Re: aussies recognized [Re: Mamabear]
thursday Offline
SJ'er with 7500+ posts

Registered: Tue Jul 18 2006
Posts: 8119
Loc: 香港
Mamabear you selfish B****, they would've all enjoyed that.

Top
#253011 - Fri Jan 11 2008 07:18 AM Re: aussies recognized [Re: thursday]
Mamabear Offline
SJ'er with 1000+ posts

Registered: Sun Nov 04 2007
Posts: 1586
Loc: Perth Western Australia
LOL.
What can I say... sometimes ya just gotta say nuffs e-nuff and do your own thing for a short time!

Top
#257495 - Tue Feb 05 2008 12:15 AM Re: aussies recognized [Re: SerreChe]
Snowhaus Offline
SJ'er with 100+ posts

Registered: Sun Nov 18 2001
Posts: 118
Loc: Aomori
SerreChe

There's nothing secret about the rumour. It's covered in the book written by the widow of one of the people who died in the avalanche(雪煙 by こすが聖絵). The rumour is that Simon and his group may have inadvertently set off the avalanche that killed those two people.

The widow makes a point of saying that no one is ever going to know the truth for sure, and that assigning blame won't bring her husband back. The rumour has been going on since the day of the avalanche, but some of the locals don't feel quite as charitable as the widow, especially since three of the Japanese guides from that trip have just been hit with "professional negligence resulting in death or injury".

With the 1 year anniversary since the avalanche around the corner, the actions of all the players involved that day (and subsequently) have been speculated on, picked apart, and judgements passed by any number of locals here. The fact of the matter is that no one is ever going to know for sure what happened.

I know it's easy to take the high moral ground from the comfort of an armchair, but for me, this whole tragedy just keeps reminding me that you should never place blind trust in any guide. Learn what you need to to make your own decisions, and don't let your ego lead you to places that put you or those around you in the path of danger.


Edited by Snowhaus (Tue Feb 05 2008 12:22 AM)

Top
#257534 - Tue Feb 05 2008 09:23 AM Re: aussies recognized [Re: Snowhaus]
snobee Offline
SJ'er with 500+ posts

Registered: Fri Nov 09 2001
Posts: 574
Loc: Takamatsu
Yes I've heard the same story.
A distinct possibility, but impossible to verify and as stated it's not going to bring back anyone. Tragic all round.

About slides in-bounds. Was discussed on here a coupla years back when it happened BIG time at Mizuho in Shimane.

The whole of Big Morning intermediate(?) course (wide, long and max @ 20deg) cracked a metre deep at the top and slid 100's of metres.
No extreme conditions.
Incredibly lucky it wasn't a Sunday as everyone in Japan would have never forgotten the name if it was.

So the simple answer is any shit can happen anytime and don't get too smug about what you think you know.

But preparation is certainly the way to go. Got my earthquake survival pack by the door.

Top
#257571 - Tue Feb 05 2008 11:33 AM Re: aussies recognized [Re: snobee]
tsondaboy Offline
SJ'er with 3000+ posts

Registered: Tue Oct 26 2004
Posts: 3542
Loc: 東京 (Tokyo)
If Simons group did start the avalanche as rumoured, then why no one in Simons group didn't get caught?

And anyway, regardless of who started the avalanche, when you guide a group of people you have to make sure that you are not exposing them to danger not only when they are skiing down a slope but also when you are traversing an area with avalanche terrain hanging above you.


Edited by tsondaboy (Tue Feb 05 2008 11:37 AM)
_________________________
████
█02█
████

Top
#257598 - Tue Feb 05 2008 01:28 PM Re: aussies recognized [Re: tsondaboy]
Captain Stag Offline
SJ'er with 1000+ posts

Registered: Wed Nov 06 2002
Posts: 1491
Loc: various
I went on a tour with the guides from Sukayu (the ones involved in this incident) I was afraid for my life to the extent that my wife and I took measures to try and provide for our own safety. We took turns going right to the front of the group (of about 30) and the other went right at the back to spot the person in front (as we were the only two with beacons). Once the first person got to the bottom they had to try and find a safe place to stop and wait (while trying not to get too far from the rest of the group who were parked right where any potential avalanche would end up) There were times though when we could not even provide for our own safety. i.e When the entire group was lead together onto a slope steep enough to avalanche. At that exposed moment the snowboard group led by other Sukayu guides who had snowshoed to the top of the slope we traversed onto, dropped in over a convex roll right above the 30 people parked in the middle of the slope. I just about shat myself.
Earlier when I was finding out if the guides had beacons on or not (as part of our self-rescue plan) the guide said that they did not have them. He said he thought they should have them but the boss thought that they didnt need them because they only went out when it was safe. We left that day saying that people were going to die there - the very next year they did.

That they can have the nerve to try and blame this tragedy on anyone but themselves is shameful. I liked the guides, they were good guys and fun to hang out with and watch ski movies with but someone needs to get prosecuted to send some sort of message to the "guide" industry

Top
#257676 - Tue Feb 05 2008 09:42 PM Re: aussies recognized [Re: Captain Stag]
Snowhaus Offline
SJ'er with 100+ posts

Registered: Sun Nov 18 2001
Posts: 118
Loc: Aomori
 Originally Posted By: Captain Stag
That they can have the nerve to try and blame this tragedy on anyone but themselves is shameful. I liked the guides, they were good guys and fun to hang out with and watch ski movies with but someone needs to get prosecuted to send some sort of message to the "guide" industry


It's not the guides who are assigning blame elsewhere. For that matter, the locals aren't really laying blame elsewhere per se. It's more that they question anyones wisdom in going out there that day. I'll be honest and say that I fall into that camp myself.

I remember that day very well because with the amount of fresh snow we had I had planned on taking the day off and going up to the mountain. When I looked at the weather forecast early that morning though, it was obvious that there was a very big and windy low pressure system that was going to sit over the Hakkoda range that day. The Hakkoda ropeway closes when wind speeds reach 25 metres per second (or about 90km per hour). I knew that this was going to happen by no later than mid-morning, so decided to just go to work instead.

At the time, I was working in the same building as the prefectural police headquarters, so when the police were notified it didn't take long to hear that there was something wrong up at Hakkoda. I was worried that people I knew might be up there so I was trying to find out as much as I could without getting in anyones way. That's when reports started coming through that foreigners were involved. I was also checking the Hakkoda ropeway website to see if they had any information. By this stage the wind speed was registering at 37m/second (about 133 km/hr).

What happened was a tragedy, but to this day I believe that every guide on the mountain that day bears responsibility for it. If they had taken a glance at the weather charts that day it would have been bleeding obvious that the weather was going to close in on them all, and badly. The alternative, that they didn't bother to look at, or didn't know how to read a weather map, pretty much by definition means they should have no right to guide anyone anywhere.

Skiing in poor visibility is part and parcel of skiing at Hakkoda. No one denies this, and anyone who has spent any amount of time on the mountain just learns to deal with it (or, indeed, revel in it). But it's one thing to know the terrain well, take responsibility for yourself and make judgement calls about what you as an individual are going to do. It's another thing when other people put their trust in you because they believe that you will make the right decisions for them and keep them out of harms way; when clients have limited knowledge of the terrain and/or experience in the prevailing conditions.

I firmly believe that hubris, and an understandable (but misguided) desire to satisfy customers who had booked out tours weeks in advance (on the part of all of the guides there that day) were what caused that accident. I've kept my mouth shut about this for the past year because I couldn't see the point of pointing fingers. But now every weekend I see skiers and boarders who are blissful in their ignorance piling out of the ropeway to follow their guide, like ducklings following their mother. I want to beg them to learn how to look after themselves rather than trusting that their guide has the know-how and judgement to keep them all safe.

I also believe that people should be willing to stand by the words that they write, even in an anonymous forum. If anyone wants to call me on it, feel free. I'm the gaijin girl telemarker in the orange jacket and grey helmet sitting with the old folk around the stove at the bottom of the ropeway.

Top
Page 2 of 2 < 1 2


Moderator:  SJ#2, SJ#3, SJ#4, SJ#5, SJBot, SJForums 
SnowJapan Chat Box
The SnowJapan Chat Box is currently closed.
Who's Online
8 Registered (Elzy, Indo, Mantas, pricere, tfcjaga, torihada, wallas, Weegeoff), 44 visible guests and 9 others.
Key: Admin, Global Mod, Mod
Forum Stats
7219 Members
11 Forums
16169 Topics
295524 Posts
178 Average daily posts (last week)
214 Posts in the last 24 hrs

Max Online: 2075 @ Fri Apr 04 2008 09:23 AM
Newest Members
CigaretteSmokingMan, jetpilot000, Jessta, Richardkorea, MuminHongKong, HongKong, DG
7219 Registered Members
SnowJapan News & Announcements
RESORT SPOTLIGHT - Furano (Furano, Hokkaido)
by SJ#4
Yesterday at 08:11 PM
SHIGA KOGEN ACCOMMODATION - Bersarooms (Shiga Kogen, Nagano)
by SJ#4
Yesterday at 05:04 PM
RESORT SPOTLIGHT - Dynaland (Takasu, Gifu Prefecture)
by SJ#4
Yesterday at 04:02 PM
About weather forecasts & snow depth data
by SJ#4
Thu Nov 20 2008 08:38 AM
HAKUBA ACCOMMODATION - White Horse House (Hakuba, Nagano)
by SJ#4
Fri Nov 14 2008 11:20 AM
Daily Reports
21st November 2008 - daily Japan snow & weather reports
by SJ#4
Yesterday at 09:12 AM
20th November 2008 - daily Japan snow & weather reports
by SJ#4
Thu Nov 20 2008 08:30 AM
SnowJapan Information
SnowJapan.com
Interview about SnowJapan
About SnowJapan
Site Map
News & Announcements
Contact Us
Forums Registration


SNOWJAPAN.COM   :   SNOWJAPAN.TV
the japan winter sports guide & community

JAPAN SKI & SNOWBOARD RESORTS
Japan Snow Resorts Index : Resorts by Prefecture : Resort Spotlights : Ski Town Maps : Resort Reviews : Resort Photos : Search Resorts
JAPAN SKI ACCOMMODATION & PLACES TO STAY
Places to Stay Index (All Regions) : Hokkaido : Nagano : Niigata : Gunma : Iwate : Yamagata : Fukushima
JAPAN SNOW & WEATHER DAILY REPORTING
Daily Reporting Index : Niseko Now : Furano Now : Hakuba Now : Nozawa Now : Shiga Kogen Now : Yuzawa Now : Naeba Now : Minakami Now : Now Calendar : Resort Webcams
JAPAN SKI TOWN GUIDES
Town Guides Index : Niseko Town Guide : Furano Town Guide : Hakuba Town Guide : Nozawa Town Guide : Shiga Kogen Town Guide : Yuzawa & Naeba Town Guide : Minakami Town Guide
GUIDES & INFORMATION
Travel Info : General Info : Services : Lessons in English : Tours & Services : Jobs Available : Features & Interviews : Photo Galleries : Reader Photo Galleries

About SnowJapan : Contact Us : Site Map : Search : Start Here!
SnowJapan © 2008
www.snowjapanforums.com